ai 我都想讀master mba course比較貴 o黎兩年駛大o左 (拎o左去賭) 所以未夠錢讀 marketing or communications都想讀 因為覺得自己學識唔夠.作者: unicorn 時間: 2005-7-11 10:04:11
this topic should actually be more appropriately answered by ice
i read many articles in the web
the general situation of hk is as follows
1. those large large organisation like
hsbc and hwl would not accept people 'fly' into their
management level because there are many 'experienced' guys inside their own company who wanna promote
2. those small size boss concern about blood-relationship and accept their relatives more than external company
3. so those mba in hongkong only hope to get certain investment related posts(you can see that 50% of the cuhk mba student come from finance)
4. my questions is
"according to current market situations are there cases that 'generalist' fly into the TOP managing posts of other organisation?"
e.g. a man who is midland property for 10 years went to cumba. this man became chun hung machinery factory director because he knows 'strategy''organisational behaviour''operational management''finance and account' 'information system' etc...
if 4. is not feasible can we conclude that
'seeking more clients is more useful that spending your time to take a mba if you are a midland property agent'?作者: CJ 時間: 2005-7-11 11:27:06
見你擺響吹水版 仲想開下玩笑. 大家居然一板一眼咁答... 嗚
好 我又正經的
There are a few strawmen in the arguments worthy to clarify.
If the usefulness of MBA is judged by whether one can jump into top management frankly there is no such dream in the world.
First Taught MBA is just one of the systematic training of business behaviour study. MBA could give one's broader view on different doctrines and skills but not the real experiences. It is dangerous to assume a MBA GPA4.0 graduate must be a better manager than a 10 years exp Manager. Otherwise all professors should be CEOs of every big corps.
Second MBA is not a VIP fast pass but just one of the entry tickets. No company will hire a guy/gal as management just because he/she is MBA.
However if one got a good MBA from a prestige school he/she will still earn a certain level of advantages. But in the long run one's track record is his/her real wealth.
Don't be innocent to complain people rely on relationship. Soft skills and human networks are very important and need to be built through time. Or you can watch TV shows like "The Apprentice" and "Survivor".作者: matthewlee 時間: 2005-7-11 17:46:50
: ? 定係落disco定bar果時用架 
ops: ?
OON"]仲好貴學費添 ![/quote]